Dutch linguistic purism

Comments

Same problem here in America: small children are taught that the nominative is "correct" in sentences like "He has more children than I " and [phone conversation] "Hello, is John there?" "This is he." But actual humans say "He has more children than me" and "Hello, is John there?" "This is John" ["This is him" sounds just as bad to a native English speaker as "This is he", for different reasons, so we avoid it.]
Prescriptivism abounds, sigh.

It always amazes me how it's possible for purists to have just enough braincells to learn grammatical theory and yet are incapable of understanding the more blatantly obvious, that languages change regardless of our personal feelings.

It's kind of like a mathematician who is capable of solving the most complex calculations and yet... doesn't know what any of it means.

Or like an architect with the most stunning designs who... doesn't understand gravity.

On another thought, while purists will obsess over what they assume to be, well, "pure", it's sometimes instructive to ask why a trend is happening to understand why the supposedly erroneous grammatical quirk is developing in the first place.

On the topic of "than I" versus "than me" in a sentence like "He has more children than me", I can imagine at least one reason to favour "me" over "I". The reason would be that "I" is not the subject and focus (ie. "he" is the subject and focus) and if we all agree that "I" is the first person singular subject pronoun, then the non-subject "me" should be preferable. Same thing with "This is him" if a speaker interprets "this" as the focus and "him" as non-focus (and hence using the oblique form).

I just tripped over a link with tonnes of explanation on the "'than I' vs. 'than me'" debate in English.

http://grammar.quickanddirtytips.com/than-I-versus-than-me.aspx

The author sums up this debate as a petty battle between "prepositionists" and "conjunctivists". I guess I should have started with that link from the beginning and spared everyone my ramble :-P

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in